اس بحث کا کچھ فیصلہ مَیں کر نہیں سکتا
گو خوب سمجھتا ہوں کہ یہ زہر ہے، وہ قند
is bahs kā kuchh faisla maiñ kar nahīñ saktā
go ḳhub samajhtā hūñ ke ye zahr hai, vo qand
I cannot settle this debate,
though I know well that this is poison and that is sugar.
Note Poem 6 of the section Aurat. qand: sugar.
About this poem
In brief
I cannot settle this debate, though I know well that one is poison and the other sugar. What use is it to speak and be blamed even more? The sons of modern civilization are already angry with me. Let woman's own insight reveal this secret; wise men are helpless and excused. Which is worth more in beauty and value: the freedom of women, or a necklace of emeralds?
The ideas
Iqbal declines to rule on women's emancipation and leaves the judgement to women themselves. The last line leaves the choice open, though it implies that a woman should not trade something precious for a passing ornament.
History and politics
Debates on purdah, education and the legal rights of Muslim women were intense in 1930s India, with Muslim women's organizations taking part.
Why it matters today
These poems are among the most debated in Iqbal's work. Some readers value their insistence on the dignity of motherhood and their critique of a culture that treats women as display; others find them limiting and paternalistic. Iqbal himself admits in the last poem that the knot is hard to untie.
Commentary: Adab AI (draft for review)