آں سخت کوش چیست کہ گیرد ز سنگ آب
محتاجِ خضر مثلِ سکندر نمی شود
an sakht-kosh chist ke girad zi sang ab
muhtaj-e-khizr misl-e-sikandar nami-shawad
What is that hard-striving thing that draws water from stone,
and does not, like Alexander, need a Khizr?
About this poem
In brief
What is that hard-striving thing that draws water from stone, and does not, like Alexander, need Khizr to find it? Pure in its way, like the glance of a tearful eye, it goes through a stream of water and its skirt is never wet. Its meaning is complete in one well-turned line; it needs no second line to finish it.
The ideas
A riddle whose answer is the sword. Its ‘water’ is the sheen of tempered steel, drawn from the whetstone; it is wet and yet never wet; and like a perfect single line of verse it says everything at one stroke. Behind the play lies Iqbal’s praise of decisive strength that needs no outside help.
History and politics
Afkar (Thoughts) is the second part of Payam-i-Mashriq (1923), a collection of longer Persian poems on nature, the self, love and action, written partly in answer to Goethe’s West-östlicher Divan.
Islamic concepts
Alexander sought the water of life with Khizr as his guide and failed; the sword finds its own ‘water’ in stone. Riddle-poems (chistan) are an old genre of Persian verse.
Why it matters today
A witty example of the Persian riddle form, often set as a puzzle before its answer is given.
Commentary: Adab AI (draft for review)