نکتہ دانِ المنی را در ارم
صحبتے افتاد با پیرِ عجم
nukta-dan-e-almani ra dar iram
suhbate uftad ba pir-e-ajam
In paradise the sage of Germany
happened to meet the old man of Persia:
Note Footnote in the edition: نوٹ: نکتہ دانِ المنی سے مراد گوئٹے ہے جس کا ڈراما ’فوسٹ‘ مشہور و معروف ہے۔ اس ڈرامے میں شاعر نے حکیم فوسٹ اور شیطان کے عہد و پیمان کی قدیم روایت کے پیرائے میں انسان کے امکانی نشوونما کے تمام مدارج اس خوبی سے بتائے ہیں کہ اس سے بڑھ کر کمالِ فن خیال میں نہیں آ سکتا۔ Printed centred in the edition.
About this poem
In brief
In paradise the sage of Germany met the old man of Persia: a poet who, like that exalted master, is no prophet but has a book! He read to the knower of ancient secrets the tale of the pact between Satan and the sage. Rumi said: you who give life to words, you hunt angels and catch God. Your thought chose seclusion in the corner of the heart and created this old world anew. You have seen the burning and music of the soul in the body; you have seen the making of the pearl inside the shell. Not everyone knows the secret of love; not everyone is worthy of this court. ‘He knows it who is fortunate and initiated: cleverness comes from Satan, and love from Adam.’
The ideas
Iqbal imagines Goethe reading Faust to Rumi in paradise. Rumi praises him for showing, through Faust’s pact with the devil, the whole growth of the human soul. Yet he adds a gentle correction from his own Masnavi: Satan’s gift is cleverness, while love is the true inheritance of Adam. Iqbal sees in Goethe a kindred spirit to Rumi, ‘no prophet but with a book’.
History and politics
Footnote in the edition (Urdu): ‘By the sage of Germany is meant Goethe, whose drama Faust is famous. In this drama the poet, through the ancient story of the pact between the sage Faust and Satan, has shown all the stages of man’s possible development so well that no greater artistic perfection can be imagined.’ Naqsh-e-Farang (Picture of the West) is the fourth part of Payam-i-Mashriq (1923), in which Iqbal answers Goethe and portrays European thinkers, poets and statesmen, setting their ideas against his own vision of the East.
Islamic concepts
The phrase ‘no prophet but has a book’ was said of Rumi’s Masnavi by Jami. The closing couplet is quoted from Rumi’s Masnavi, as the printed attribution shows.
Why it matters today
Often cited as Iqbal’s tribute to Goethe and as a bridge between Rumi and European literature.
Commentary: Adab AI (draft for review)