میں بھی حاضر تھا وہاں، ضبطِ سخن کر نہ سکا
حق سے جب حضرتِ مُلّا کو ملا حکمِ بہشت
maiñ bhī hāzir thā vahāñ, zabt-e-suḳhan kar na sakā
haq se jab hazrat-e-mullā ko milā hukm-e-bihisht
I too was there, and could not hold my tongue,
when the reverend mullah received God's order for paradise.
Note Nazm 18 of Bal-i-Jibril. zabt-e-sukhan: restraint of speech.
About this poem
In brief
The poet was present when God ordered the mullah into paradise, and could not hold his tongue. He said: Lord, forgive me, but he will not enjoy the houris, the wine and the banks of the stream. Paradise is no place for argument and quarrel and 'I say'; debate and dispute are this servant of God's nature. His work is to teach nations and sects to quarrel, and in paradise there is no mosque, no church and no synagogue!
The ideas
A gentle satire on the quarrelsome cleric. His joy lies in disputation and sectarian division, so a paradise without rival places of worship would bore him. Iqbal mocks religion reduced to argument.
History and politics
Reflects the sectarian polemics common in early twentieth-century India among Muslim groups and between communities.
Islamic concepts
Paradise is described in the Quran as free of idle talk and quarrelling (56:25-26). Kunisht is a synagogue or fire-temple.
Why it matters today
Often quoted on sectarianism.
Commentary: Adab AI (draft for review)