وجود است ایں کہ بینی یا نمود است
حکیمِ ما چہ مشکلہا کشود است
wujud ast in ki bini ya numud ast
hakim-e ma chih mushkil-ha kushud ast
“Is what you see being, or mere appearance?”
What problems our philosopher has solved!
Note Printed under the numeral 5, which opens a new group of quatrains in this section.
About this poem
In brief
The philosopher debates whether the world is real or only appearance and claims to have solved great problems. He has written a book on pearl-diving without ever entering the sea.
The ideas
Ironic critique of philosophy divorced from experience: truth must be lived, not only theorised.
History and politics
Huzur-e ‘Alam-e Insani (In the Presence of Mankind) turns from the Muslim community to humanity at large. It opens with a half-title page bearing a couplet from Javid Nama and is printed under the heading Tamhid (Prelude) in numbered groups of quatrains on selfhood, struggle, certainty and the dignity of man. Armaghan-i-Hijaz (The Gift of the Hijaz) was published in November 1938, seven months after Iqbal’s death. Its Persian part, written in his last years when he longed to make the pilgrimage to Mecca and Medina but was too ill to travel, is a sequence of du-baiti quatrains (rubaiyat in the folk metre of Baba Tahir) arranged in five ‘presences’: before God (Huzur-e Haq), before the Prophet (Huzur-e Risalat), before the Muslim community (Huzur-e Millat), before mankind (Huzur-e ‘Alam-e Insani), and to the companions of the path (Ba Yaran-e Tariq). The book closes with a short Urdu part.
Islamic concepts
The debate on wujud (being) in Islamic philosophy and Sufism, e.g. wahdat al-wujud.
Why it matters today
Quoted on theory without practice.
Commentary: Adab AI (draft for review)