کلامِ اقبالIqbal Repository
Review edition: the Urdu and Persian texts are checked against Iqbal Academy Pakistan editions; English translations and commentary are drafts awaiting review.

19 July 1927

Speech on the resolution regarding filling of posts by open competitive examination

Speeches and Statements of IqbalAbout 5 min readDraft text

Long paragraphs are broken into shorter ones for easier reading. The numbers in the margin count the paragraphs of each piece. Notes in square brackets are the compiler’s, as printed.

1

Sir, after the Honourable the Finance Member’s' speech, which to my mind constitutes a most crushing reply to the resolution as framed,^ it is hardly possible for anyone in this House to make a substantial addition to the discussion. However, I cannot but admire the innocent idealism of Sardar Ujjal Singh, which idealism, like all idealisms, sees everything except realities. I can assure my honourable friend that the principle of competition, pure and simple, is absolutely inapplicable in this country, especially in this province. I suppose many honourable members of this House know that such a non-communal institution as the Punjab University has had to adopt the system of fictitious roll numbers in the various University examinations The examiner, according to this system, does not know as to the caste or creed or colour of the candidate whose paper he is examining or the college from which he comes.

This system was adopted because it was feared that Hindu examiners might fail Muslim candidates and Muslim examiners might fail Hindu candidates. (Voices: Shame). Yes, it is a shameful thing, but it does exist. With all that both Hindu and Muslim candidates leave certain marks in their examination papers to indicate to the examiner the candidate’s caste or creed. Only the other day, I was reading the LL.B. examination papers. I found the number “786” which is the numerical value of an Arabic formula and on others I found “Om” marks meant to invoke the blessing of God as well as to reveal to the examiner the community of the candidate.

Such is the state of things in a non-communal institution. Take another instance. During the recent riots in Lahore, both Hindu and Muslim citizens went in deputations to the Deputy Commissioner on several occasions — each community complaining of the investigating officers belonging to the opposite community. I happened to be a member of one such deputation.

2

f Voices: Shame). It is not a matter to be ashamed of. We have to see things as they are; and it is a pity that they have come to such a pass You know. Sir, what the Deputy Commissioner told us. I think he was perfectly right in saying what he did. He said: “Before the Reforms scheme came into operation, there were 120 British officers in the police department, but that they were only 68 now. We have not got a sufficient number of British officers. Both communities want European officers.”

3

My friend. Pandit Nanak Chand, is unfortunately not here at the present moment. He told us that Government had removed the colour distinction, so that the posts-which formerly went to British gentlemen now go to Hindus and Muslims; but I assure my friend that Government had made a very great mistake and I would welcome if there were more British officers. (Voices: No, no). I fully realise my responsibility when I say this and I also realise the meaning of this voice of “no, no.” I am not enamoured of that false and shallow nationalism which speaks like this. (Dr. Shaikh Muhammad Alam: Everybody is not the same). Well, it may be so, yet the talk of a united nationalism is futile and will perhaps remain so for a long time to come.

The word has existed on the lips of the people of this country for the last fifty years and like a hen it has cackled a great deal without laying a single egg. However, I will tell you that the state of this country is such that it is not possible for us to introduce the principle of competition pure and simple. The best method for the country is the one indicated by Sir Geoffrey de Montmorency in his speech, that is to say, the principle of competition tempered by selection and nomination.

4

One other thing I should like to point out. I was very glad to hear the honourable member for Simla\ I mean his advocacy of the Untouchables in an almost apostolic tone I welcome it though I do not know what Pandit Madan Mohan Malviya’s verdict would be in this matter (L. Mohan Lal: It is the same as mine). Only a short time ago he excommunicated one of his nearest relatives because he had given his daughter to a Brahmin of an inferior caste. (L. Mohan Lal: He did not).

It was in the papers and Pandit Madan Mohan Malviya was called upon to publish a reply to open letters which were addressed to him and he published no contradiction. However, I welcome the change, if it is not in theory alone and I hope that through the efforts of my friend, the honourable member for Simla, untouchability will be removed in this province. In Southern India we hear that when a Brahmin is constrained to talk to an Untouchable he must talk to some wall or tree near-by and the Untouchable too has to address, in reply, the same wall or the tree since the Brahmin is too sacred to be addressed by a Sudra. I shall welcome the day when such bans are entirely removed and the Hindus of this province adopt better principles of equality.

5

Sir, I need not say anything more with regard to the principle of competition. My friend has pointed out certain defects in the present system which he has enumerated He refers to the success of the principle of competition in other countries. I must say that the state of things in this country is totally different to the state of things in other countries. For this reason the principles the application of which is good in other countries would not apply to this country. In this country one community is always aiming at the destruction of the other community. Therefore the power in whose hands lies the destiny of this country must adopt a line of action which is calculated equally to elevate all communities that form the population of this country. It has been argued that the present system tends to retard the progress of what my friend called nationality.

Well, I do not know whether it is desirable to become a nation. It is a proposition which can be controverted but assuming that it is so, I would suggest that it is first desirable to develop mutual trust in the communities of this country. The present state of things is such that the communities do not trust each other; they have no faith in each other. When we meet each other we talk of nationalism, we talk of philanthropy and of love of mankind. Only a few days ago a friend of mine told me that he had overheard two Hindu gentlemen talking One of them asked the other as to what should be our policy now. The other gentleman said: Let nationalism be on your lips, but fix your gaze always on your own community.

Source: Speeches and Statements of Iqbal, compiled by “Shamloo”, Al-Manar Academy, Lahore, 1944 (Delhi scan https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.220327; other copies in.ernet.dli.2015.51949 and the 1948 printing speechesandstatementsofiqbal used to correct the scanned text).