Statement further explaining the postponement of the meeting of the Executive Board of the All-India Muslim Conference issued on the 6th July 1932.
I have read the proceedings of the public meeting held by certain prominent members of the All-India Muslim Conference at Allahabad on July 4. I welcome the formation of an Independent Party within the Conference. In my address to the Lahore session of the Muslim Conference 1 said as follows; The guidance offered to the community is not always independently conceived, and the result is ruptures, sometimes at critical moments, within our political organisations. Thus these organizations cannot properly develop the kind of discipline which is absolutely essential to the life and power of political bodies To remedy this evil I suggest that the Indian Muslims should have only one political organization with provincial and district branches all over the country. Call it whatever you like; what is essential is that its constitution must be such as to make it possible for any school of political thought to come into power and to guide the community according to its own ideas and' methods. In my opinion this is the only way to make ruptures impossible, and to reintegrate and discipline our scattered forces to the best interests of Islam in India.
I have, therefore, no doubt that in forming a party within the Conference, Maulana Hasrat Mohani and others have taken a step in the right direction.
I think, however, that the Muslims of India are entitled to know my view of the situation created by the resignation of Maulana Shafi Daudi and the resolution passed by the public meeting at Allahabad protesting against what they call my action in postponing the meeting of the Executive Board which was to have been held on July 3 I honestly believe that Maulana Shafi Daudi is not at all justified in his action- I requested him immediately after the publication of his resignation in the Press to withdraw it and to settle matters amicably with Syed Zakir All and others.
As to the postponement of the meeting of the 15S Executive Board what I did was simply to advise postponement on certain grounds. This advice I am convinced was perfectly sound not only because of the innumerable telegrams received by Maulana Shafi Daudi, Dr. Shafaat Ahmad Khan and myself but also because of the fact that a meeting of the Working Committee held at Simla, where I was unfortunately unable to be present, had authorised Maulana Shafi Daudi to postpone the meeting in case, in his.opinion, there was no likelihood of the communal decision being announced by July 3.
This authorisation was unanimously accepted by all members of the Working Committee who were present Maulana Shafi Daudi too willingly accepted the responsibility. Why he has not mentioned this fact in his resignation or subsequent statements it is not possible for me to say.
In the circumstances it is unfair to me to say that I acted as a dictator. According to my judgment, postponement was desired by a majority of members of the Conference My personal opinion was the same. After giving the matter most anxious consideration I arrived at the conclusion that while it was the duty of the community to fight the Government in case the communal decision was not favourable to Muslims, I ought not to advise them to start any kind of direct action merely because the Government was guilty of not announcing the communal decision within a certain time-limit This frank statement of facts will, I hope, enable the Muslims to see whether my advice for postponement of the meeting of the Executive Board was inspired by Simla dictates.
In my private and public life I have never followed another man’s conscience. I regard the man who is capable of following another’s conscience when the most important interests of the community are at stake as unworthy of Islam and humanity.
Let me make it perfectly clear that the cautious behaviour of those who desired postponement should not be so interpreted as to mean that they are less anxious than others to act on the Lahore resolution if necessity for action arises Until such necessity arises the community should hold its forces in reserve. Wisdom hes not in wasting one’s energy on unessentials but in saving it for expenditure on issues which really matter.