Statement on the Lucknow Conference of Nationalist Muslim Leaders, issued on the 8th October 1932.
I returned from Simla to Lahore on Friday and found a telegram from Shaikh Abdul Majid Sindhi, President of the Khilafat Conference, awaiting me. Mr. Sindhi asked my opinion about holding a conference of Muslim leaders with a view to some sort of a settlement with the majority community. I wired to him that in the absence of any definite proposals from the majority community such a conference would be inadvisable and futile.
The same evening I received another telegram from Mr. Sindhi informing me that my reply had reached him too late and that an informal conference of Muslim leaders had been decided upon. He asked me to participate in the deliberations of this conference. In reply I requested him to reconsider his decision and since I believed such a conference to be inexpedient as well as logically unwarranted, I informed him of my inability to participate in its deliberations.
Since then I have received telegrams from various places asking me to hold a special session of the All-India Muslim Conference to reiterate the position of the Conference and counter the Bombay move. In This conference was a sequel to talks in Bombay between Pandit Madan Mohan Malviya, Maulana Shaukat All, Shaikh Abdul Majid Sindhi and Maulana Abul Kalam Azad, etc.
these circumstances I consider it my duty to voice the community’s strong opposition to the proposed Lucknow conference. In the absence of definite proposals from Hindu leaders I fail to see what we are asked to discuss in this conference.
The Muslims of India have always shown readiness for a mutual settlement with other communities, but the way which is now being adopted is not the way to a settlement with Hindus but to disunity in our own ranks which we have consolidated with great difficulty.
To treat the question of electorates lightly and reopen it in spite of the community’s clear verdict, as embodied in the resolutions of the Muslim Conference and the Muslim League, is a most inadvisable course which may have far-reaching consequences for the community. In the wider interests of the community and the country this question should be considered as closed for the time being. There are before us other questions of far greater importance than that of joint versus separate electorates. Nor are separate electorates really contrary to nationalist ideas.
I consider the proposed conference harmful to the interests of Islam and India and an absolute waste of time. I hope that the sponsors of the conference will reconsider their position. The Muslim community should now be called upon to look forward to the solution of important constitutional problems lying ahead instead of being dragged back to the problems which have already cost us many bitter controversies but which we have now left behind.