تھی خوب حضورِ علما باب کی تقریر
بیچارہ غلط پڑھتا تھا اعرابِ سمٰوٰت
thī ḳhub huzūr-e-ulamā Bāb kī taqrīr
bechāra ġhalat paṛhtā thā i'rāb-e-samavat
The Bab's speech before the scholars was fine,
but the poor man misread the vowels of 'samawat'.
Note Poem 42 of the section Islam aur Musalman. A satire. irab: Arabic vowel marks. samawat: the heavens.
About this poem
In brief
The Bab's speech before the scholars was fine; only the poor man kept misreading the vowel marks of 'samawat'. The scholars smiled at his mistake. He said: you do not know my stations. Now, thanks to my imamate, the verses of the Quran are free: they were imprisoned in their vowel marks!
The ideas
A satire on a claimant to religious authority who turns his ignorance of Arabic grammar into a claim of spiritual freedom. Iqbal mocks the use of mystical rank to excuse error.
History and politics
Sayyid Ali Muhammad Shirazi (1819-1850), called the Bab ('the Gate'), founded the Babi movement in Iran. At his examination by clerics in Tabriz in 1848 he was mocked for errors in Arabic grammar; this is the story the poem draws on. He was executed in 1850. The Bab is revered by Babis and by followers of the Baha'i Faith, who have faced long persecution; the poem reflects Iqbal's polemic and the history of that controversy.
Islamic concepts
Irab: the short-vowel marks of Arabic, essential for the correct reading of the Quran. Samawat: 'the heavens'.
Commentary: Adab AI (draft for review)