وہی اصلِ مکان و لامکاں ہے
مکاں کیا شے ہے، اندازِ بیاں ہے
vahī asl-e-makān o lā-makāñ hai
makāñ kyā shai hai, andāz-e-bayāñ hai
He is the root of place and of the placeless;
what is place? Only a way of speaking.
Note Ghazal 14 of Part 1 of Bal-i-Jibril. The edition prints it without a title; the title here is its first line.
About this poem
In brief
God is the root of both the world of space and the realm beyond it; 'place' itself is only a way of speaking. How could Khizr, the guide, explain where God is? It would be like a fish asking where the river is.
The ideas
Iqbal says that God is not located anywhere, because space itself depends on Him. Our words for place are only a manner of speech. We live in God as a fish lives in water: so close that the question 'where' makes no sense.
History and politics
The quatrain reflects Iqbal's philosophical interest in space and time, which he discussed with reference to modern physics in his Reconstruction lectures.
Islamic concepts
Khizr is the mysterious guide of the Quran (18:65-82) who knows hidden things. The Quran says God is 'closer than the jugular vein' (50:16) and 'wherever you turn, there is the face of God' (2:115).
Why it matters today
A gentle answer to the question children and philosophers ask: 'Where is God?'
Commentary: Adab AI (draft for review)