Speech on the Budget, 1927-28 delivered in the Punjab Legislative Council on the 5th March 1927.
Sir, I would pass a few general remarks on the Budget that was presented to the Council on the 28th of February. No one who has read the speech made by the Honourable the Finance Member and the memorandum prepared by the Finance Secretary can remain unimpressed by the remarkable lucidity of these documents, I must say as a layman that I have learned a great deal from them. In fact the Finance Secretary has very candidly suggested the criticism to which the general financial position of the province is open. He has told us that we spent 23 lakhs more than our income last year; and we are going to spend 60 lakhs more than our income this year: that is to say, in two years we shall have spent 83 lakhs more than our income.
The question, therefore, arises whether we are justified in spending large sums of money on development. The general financial position, however, in view of the various considerations set forth in the review by the Finance Secretary, is satisfactory; though he has told’ us that it is not permissible to reduce the taxes in the absence of permanent funds Now, so far as reduction of taxes is concerned, I will offer a few remarks presently. But in view of the fact that the general financial position of this province is satisfactory some provision ought to have been made in the Budget at least for rural sanitation as well as for medical relief for women. In fact, medical relief for women is badly needed in this province and no provision seems to have been made for this in the Budget.
I would, therefore, draw your attention. Sir, and the attention of the honourable members of the Council to this very important consideration. As to the reduction of taxes, I suppose the Finance Secretary, when he prepared his admirable review of the financial position of the province, was not aware of the remission made by the Government of India. We now know that 86 lakhs have been remitted (Mr. H. D. Craik: May be remitted) of which 60 lakhs are recurring and 26 lakhs nonrecurring. If this large amount is remitted, as I hope it will be remitted, my submission is that money should be spent towards the reduction of taxes, that is to say, towards the removal of the anomaly which exists in our system of taxation. The anomaly I mean is this. that we do not apply the principle of progression in the case of land revenue whereas we apply that principle in the case of income-tax.
The reason why this principle is not applied to land revenue is sometimes found in the barbarous theory that all land belongs to the Crown. Neither in ancient India nor even in the days of the Mughals the sovereign ever claimed universal ownership. This is the historical aspect of the matter. The Taxation Enquiry Committee also has accepted this position, though half the members of that Committee were of the opinion that land revenue could not be described as a tax, the other half being of the opinion that it is in the nature of a tax.
But the fact remains that in this country the sovereign never claimed any such rights. We are told that the Mughals claimed such rights; but the people of the Punjab owned and possessed the land of this country long before the race of Babar entered into history— the unmistakable lesson of which is that Crowns come and go; the people alone are immortal:
سکندر رفت و شمشیر و علم رفتخراجِ شہر و گنجِ کان و یم رفتامم را از شہاں پایندہ تر داںنمی بینی کہ ایراں ماند و جم رفت
Iqbal, Payam-i-Mashriq (Lala-e-Tur)
I submit, therefore, that in this twentieth century such a theory, even if it existed in any country at any time, cannot hold good. In case this money is remitted we should apply it towards the reduction of taxes. We should apply the principle of progression to land revenue. At present all land is subject to land revenue. Whether a man holds two kanals of land, he is liable to pay the land revenue. In the case of income-tax the principle of ability or the principle of progression is applied — that is to say, there is a graduated scale and some people do not pay income-tax at all. My submission, therefore, is that the Council should consider the question of the reduction of taxes in the light of this principle