Speech on the cut motion on Government’s demand for grant under ‘Education’ delivered in the Punjab Legislative Council on the 10th March, 1927.
Sir, the question of education is extremely important and I am glad to see that the honourable members who have preceded me have spoken with great enthusiasm on the subject. They have emphasised the fact that education is a common interest, that it affects all classes of people of this land — Hindus, Muslims, Sikhs, capitalists and labourers — but they have not looked at the problem from the stand-point of a foreign government. A disinterested foreign government is a contradiction in terms. The foreign government in this country wants to keep the people Ignorant. A foreign government is a kind of Roman Catholic Church trying to suppress all the agencies that tend to enlighten the laity.
The honourable Pandit Nanak Chand and Chaudhri Afzal Haq gentleman who preceded me has conclusively proved from facts and figures given in the ‘Report on the Progress of Education in the Punjab for the year 1925-26’ that we are wasting tremendous amounts of money on education with no results. Can anybody deny in this House or outside this House that mass education is absolutely essential in the interest of the people? Primary education, secondary education, professional or vocational education are all various aspects of the same problem of mass education. Well, the ancient sages of this country used to say that the world is maya or illusion.
I do not know whether the world outside this House is maya but I am absolutely certain that whatever happens inside this House is nothing but maya though I must say that I am also a part and parcel of this illusion. Let me take the various stages of education, that is to say, primary education, secondary education and higher education. Now, whatever interpretations may be put upon this Report, one fact is perfectly clear from it, and it is this — that the principle of compulsion must be immediately applied. If you turn to page 2 of the Report — I mean the ‘Proceedings of the Ministry of Education’, you will find the following:
“Thus, as the Director has observed, compulsion should not be regarded as an ideal of distant future, but rather as a present and practical means of ensuring that the sums of money devoted to vernacular education are spent to the most fruitful purpose. It is hoped, therefore, that local authorities and all concerned will take immediate and effective steps toward Pandit Nanak Chand a more rapid extension of the compulsory principle.”
At the same time the education expert, Mr. Mayhew, whom I have the privilege to know personally, has told us that, in so far as the voluntary system is concerned, the present outlook is gloomy. This is an argument in favour of the fact that the principle of compulsion must be applied. We are told that it is applied in the case of 42 municipalities and some 400, perhaps more than 400, rural areas. What happens there? We do not know anything from this Report.
We do not know whether any persons were ever tined for not sending their children to schools. Nor do we know the number of teachers who are teaching in these schools. Unless we are given sufficient information, we cannot say what these rural areas and municipalities are doing? As far as my personal information goes, I can tell the members of this House, that nothing is being done and that there is an absolute waste of money. Only you have opened some schools and ostensibly compulsory, but not at all different to voluntary primary schools.
I submit. Sir, that these schools are doing nothing at all, and in fact the way in which they are working does not amount to the adoption of the principle of compulsion The Report virtually establishes that the principle of compulsion must be adopted. In fact in the amount of money that we are wasting on primary education the Report before us finds an argument in favour of the adoption of this principle. It says that a very large number of boys ]om the first class but the money spent upon them is wasted as most of them fail to reach the higher classes.
If you are spending a very large amount of money on them, then it is your duty to see that they reach the higher classes Make them reach the higher classes by compulsion. Therefore my submission is that in so far as primary education is concerned, it is absolutely necessary in the interest of this province to adopt the principle of compulsion at once.