Speech on the Budget, 1929-30 delivered in the Punjab Legislative Council on the 4th March, 1929.
Sir, I am afraid the Budget which has been presented to this Council presents a financial position which, in the words of the Honourable the Finance Member even a confirmed optimist cannot regard as entirely satisfactory. And the statement with which this Budget is presented is so concise and so absolutely frank that its very frankness makes extremely difficult for the reader to criticise it. However, there are certain points which must be noticed. One remarkable feature of this Budget is, and this is the first Budget that has this feature, that the contribution to the Government of India finds no place in it.
But its most unfortunate feature is that after five years’ continuous prosperity we are, for the first time, confronting a deficit Budget. The small increase in Excise and Stamps is no source of satisfaction, because it means an increase in drunkenness and litigation which reflects credit neither on the people nor on the Government. On the expenditure side of the Budget for 1928-29 the only excess is under Irrigation and Jails The increase under Irrigation is due to floods in August, and the increase under Jails is due to an increase in the number of prisoners and also to higher prices of food. Well, floods are a natural phenomenon and cannot be prevented, but unless we are complete fatalists, crime is a preventable affair.
If appropriate methods to prevent crime are adopted, it, to a very large extent, can be prevented. The present state of affairs is such that the man who steals cattle worth Rs. 10 is sent to jail for two years, and I think this is very largely responsible for the increase in the number of prisoners in the jails In the Budget Estimate of 1929-30 the first thing which I would like to note is Education. Graph No. 4 in the Memorandum tells us that the amount allotted to Education is 1,81.
In the statement of the Honourable the Finance Member on page 6 we find it is 1,67. I was not able to understand these figures, because if 12 lakhs on new expenditure are added to 1,67 the sum is 1,79 and not 1,81. (Mr. J. G. Beazley: May I explain. Sir, that that figure includes expenditure on works, repairs and stationery). Very well. Sir. The state of things so far as Education is concerned is very very disappointing. I was going to say. awful In 1922-23, 55 new schools in all came up for grants-in-aid, out of which 16 were Islamia schools.
The total amount of grants made to schools was Rs. 1,21,906, out of which a sum of Rs. 29,214 went to Muslim schools. In 1926-27, the total amount of grant to high schools was 1,22,287 and the same amount, namely, Rs. 29,214 went to Muslim schools, *,e., 23 per cent of the total amount. In 1927-28 the total amount of grant was Rs. 10,13,154 and the share of Muslim schools was Rs. 2,04,330, that is to say, the population which is most backward in education and most indebted got only 2 lakhs out of 10.
This is a state of affairs which cannot be regarded as satisfactory. Yet we are told that there are savings in the beneficent departments which Mr. Penny describes as instances of over-budgeting 1 am not at all opposed to spending large sums on education nor is it the purpose of this criticism to raise any such opposition: but I should submit that the money spent on education must be spent carefully and must be distributed equally especially in places where people are backward and too poor to pay for education. However, I need not dwell on this point because I believe it will be taken up when the motions for cuts come up before the House.
I would now like to say a few words about capital expenditure. In 1928-29 the budgeted estimate for capital expenditure charged to revenue was 1,81 lakhs it was later on raised to 1,89 and the revised estimate shows Rs. 2,12 lakhs For 1929-39, the capital expenditure is expected to be Rs. 1,54 lakhs. Since extraordinary receipts will not amount to much it is proposed to borrow Rs. 1,40 lakhs from the Provincial Loans Fund This is a very regrettable state of affairs. The province is already in debt. On pages 22-23 of the Budget you will find the exact position of the province. It will be seen that the loans from the public amount to 3 crores while the loans from the Government of India prior to 31st March and the years subsequent ^Finance Secretary (now Financial Commissioner, Development) thereto amount in the aggregate to about 26 crores.
Of course, this sum does not include the loans which have been sanctioned from 1st March 1929. We are now compelled to borrow another sum of 1,40 lakhs in spite of what the Honourable the Finance Member says at page 4 of his statement which runs as follows:
“It has been found impossible to proceed with the full programme of buildings and roads and it is contemplated that 48 lakhs less will be expended under this head in 1929-30 than is shown in the revised estimate for 1928-29. It is also contemplated to reduce transfers to the Revenue Reserve Fund to 5 lakhs only instead of the 15 lakhs budgeted for 1928-29.”
I think it was Charles Lamb who said that mankind are really divided into two classes, creditors and debtors In so far as this province is concerned, if we drop the religious labels, — Hindu and Muslim — and substitute the economic labels, lenders and borrowers, Lamb’s remark is perfectly true But my fear is that this province, as a whole, may now be made a permanent member of debtor class. Thus the present financial position is very disappointing and it is not an easy matter to discover new sources of revenue.
However, I venture to make a suggestion. In the first place,I should like the Government to move the Government of India to provincialise income-tax. That would improve our position to some extent. I may in the next place suggest the imposition of death duties as they have in England. (Revenue Member ■ Living duties would be more appropriate)! These would be living duties because it is the living who would have to pay them. Some limit such as those inheriting property to the value of Rs. 20,000 or 30,000 may be fixed. Next we should try reduction of high salaries and purchase of our machinery from the cheapest markets.