Speech on the resolution regarding application of the principles of assessment of income-tax to the assessment of land revenue delivered in the Punjab Legislative Council on the 23rd February, 1928.
Sir, I am glad to see that the Honourable Member for Revenue did not make any attempt to justify the present system of assessment on the basis of State ownership of land. He left it very wisely for the honourable member for Simla. I am afraid this offers a fitting occasion for the application of that humorous Punjabi proverb chor nalon pand kalhi, that is to say, the property stolen is readier to run away than the thief. (A voice: Who is the thief?) You may understand it as you like. Since the honourable member for Simla has raised this point, I think it necessary to dispose of it with a few remarks Let me tell the honourable representative for Simla that the first European author to refute this theory was the Frenchman Perron in the year 1777. Later in 1830 Briggs made a very extensive inquiry as to the law and practice in India and relating to the theory of State ownership of land.
He gives in his book an accurate description of the laws of Manu, of Muslim law and the practices prevailing in the various parts of India — Bengal, Malwa, the Punjab, etc., and arrives at the conclusion that in no period in the history of India the State ever claimed the proprietorship of land. In the time of Lord Curzon, however, this theory was put forward, but the Taxation Committee’s report which was published sometime ago has come to a very clear finding that this theory has no basis at all. That is, I believe, the reason why the Honourable Revenue Member has not tried to defend the present system on the ground of that theory, (Revenue Member: Not necessarily).
If you agree. Sir, the Honourable Member may argue on the basis of that theory if he likes. But in his first speech on the subject he did not try to defend the present system of assessment on the basis of that theory. (Revenue Member: I did not want to).
And we take it that the Government does not rely upon that. However, we have to see, in the first place, how far the present system of assessment is just. Workable it is and sanctioned by a very old tradition; but we have first to sec whether it has justice on its side or not. My submission is that it is not at all just. The injustice of it is perfectly clear. If a man happens to be landowner, big or small does not matter, he has to pay land revenue.
But if a man earns from sources other than land, less than two thousand rupees a year you don’t tax him at all. That is where injustice comes in. Nobody can deny that the system is unjust. It is no argument to say that since there are insuperable difficulties in the way of the removal of this injustice, therefore it must be perpetuated. We must admit that there is injustice and we ought to seek proper remedies in order to remove the injustice in so far as it is possible.
I have no hesitation in admitting that there are serious difficulties in the way of the application of the principle of income-tax to land revenue. As a matter of fact one reason why I withdrew a more or less similar resolution which I sent in last time was this, that I felt that there were serious difficulties and the matter had to be further investigated, although the difficulties that were then in my mind have not at all been referred to by the Honourable Revenue Member, and I need not mention them until I have heard what other members have got to say. (A voice: You cannot speak again), I do not then want to tell the House the difficulties that struck me. (A voice: Is that a secret?) It is an open secret to which the Official Secrets Act does not apply.
The arguments that the learned Member for Revenue put forward are, in the main, two. In the first place, he argues that we are constantly in need of money: the province needs money for its development, and that the Government does not practise alchemy. T think the Government need not practise alchemy so long as they have in their pocket all the tillers 'of the soil whose hard work turns dust into gold. But this kind of argument can be applied in defence of any kind of evil practice which brings the required amount of money.
But assuming that this argument has force, I submit that the deficiency caused in the land revenue by the adoption of a different system of land revenue may be met in other ways For instance, we can reduce the expenditure on administration. We can lower the limit of taxable income under the Income-Tax Act. We can spend less on the so-called development which is a very dignified expression for something which has not brought us anything so far. We can further meet it from the remissions made by the Government of India.
Again the Honourable the Revenue Member has tried to meet the argument that the whole burden of land revenue falls on the shoulders of the consumer or by showing that the consumer indirectly shares in that burden. The argument is plausible; but personally I feel very doubtful of its validity. One must not forget the condition of things prevailing in this province. We gave up batai long ago. (Revenue Member: Not yet). Practically, the Land Revenue Bill does not recognise hatai. (Revenue Member: There is no amended Act yet). In general practice batai is given up I do not know what would be the attitude of my zamindar friends. On economic grounds, probably the batai system, to my mind, is better.
However, the prices of the produce of the land are determined by the demand of the consumer and the prices, as the Honourable the Finance Member has pointed out, determine the amount of land revenue. But the moment the land revenue is determined, then it becomes a fixed amount for a number of years. If after the fixing of the amount prices go up, then there is a chance for the seller to profit by the rise of prices; but if the prices fall down, then I am afraid, the consumer has really no share in the burden of land revenue. (Revenue Member: If prices rise?} Well it is a matter of chance. They may rise or they may fall. (Revenue Member: Then the consumer pays).
I have a serious doubt about this. The whole situation depends upon chance. If prices rise, it goes to his profit; if the prices fall down the argument which the Honourable the Revenue Member put forward has no application. The consumer helps in the determination of land revenue, but after the land revenue is fixed, then the whole thing is left to chance. We should not forget that the production is also uncertain especially in areas where the land is baram. Again the Honourable the Revenue Member argued that this system should either be continued or be given up at once.
There is no third alternative possible. In this connection I beg to say that this is not the spirit of the resolution moved by the honourable member from Rohtak*. The spirit of the resolution is that if you recognise that the present system is unjust then do something to make a beginning towards the remedying of that injustice. Definite suggestions were made by the honourable members who preceded me in connection with this matter. I think it is easy to do so without definitely introducing the principle of income-tax in our land revenue system it can be done by amending section 48 of the Land Revenue Act.
I have already submitted an amendment to this effect, though I am afraid the prospect for that amendment is not very bright. I, therefore, suggest that holdings, not exceeding five bighas and situated in the non-irrigated areas where the produce is practically fixed, should not be liable to the payment of land revenue. This can be done without deciding the question whether the principle of income-tax should be applied to assessment of land or not. If you lay down that a holding not exceeding five bighas is revenue-free, I do not think there will be very great deficiency in the land revenue. At any rate, if there is a large deficiency, I think it can probably be met by reducing expenditure in other directions.
Lastly, as regards the argument of the Honourable the Revenue Member, or rather the fear that he expressed that this resolution may mean the death of the baby, the Land Revenue Bill, and the apprehensions that it will amount to infanticide. Well, in these days of birth-control, I think infanticide does not matter especially when we know that the child is going to be a very wicked one. I do not think it is demanding too much if the holdings to the extent of five bighas should be declared revenue-free.
I hope that Government will give serious consideration to this point. Personally I agree even if you make it less than five bighas. (Revenue Member; Five acres). An economic holding in this province is about ten or eleven bighas. At any rate, five bighas is half the economic holding. I do not think that remission of land revenue in the case of persons holding five bighas would cause very great deficiency. (Ch. Afzal Haq: Only two crores). My calculation was that it was much less than two crores. (Revenue Member: Not quite that if you let out only the two acre men). Two and a half crores. (Revenue Member: Gunah-i-be lazzat) If you commit this fruitless sin, it would show that there is at least some sense of justice in you. Reference was also made by one of the honourable members to sending a kind of commission of inquiry to Russia I am afraid several commissions have already been sent to Russia, though not from this country.
My honourable friend is probably not aware of the causes that led to the Russian revolt. It is not necessary to detail those causes: a good deal of literature has sprung up since the Russian revolt concerning the things that happened and the system that has been adopted there. Books written by such men as Bertrand Russel and others who have devoted their time to economic questions have appeared. But I think my honourable friend Pandit Nanak Chand has already given an effective reply to the proposal made by Ch. Afzal Haq that at the present moment, the Punjab zamindar is not ready to give up the right of private ownership.
In this country, there are petty landholders, there are proprietors with two bighas, two kanals. They are practically like tenants, yet are not willing to give up the right of private ownership. My submission, therefore, is that Government should give some consideration to the demand embodied in this resolution; they should give some relief to the small proprietor, the produce of whose land is obviously insufficient to maintain his family.