کلامِ اقبالIqbal Repository
Review edition: the Urdu and Persian texts are checked against Iqbal Academy Pakistan editions; English translations and commentary are drafts awaiting review.

10 August 1932

Statement explaining the resolution passed by the Working Committee of the All-India Muslim Conference regarding Sikh-Muslim conversations

Speeches and Statements of IqbalAbout 2 min readDraft text

Long paragraphs are broken into shorter ones for easier reading. The numbers in the margin count the paragraphs of each piece. Notes in square brackets are the compiler’s, as printed.

1

I consider it my duty to make it perfectly clear why the Working Committee of the All-India Muslim Conference at its last meeting in Delhi passed the resolution relating to the Sikh-Muslim conversations in Simla.

2

Firstly, while fully recognising the value of communal concord, the members of the Committee thought that such conversations at the present moment might delay the Government announcement and still further aggravate th Sikh-Muslim situation in the Punjab.

3

Secondly, in view of certain statements issued to the Press by some of the Sikh leaders, they felt that nothing was likely to come out of these conversations. This feeling is amply justified by the latest statement of Sir Jogendra published to-day. In his letter to me Sir Jogendra clearly mentioned the figures 88 and 87 for Muslims and non-Muslims respectively.

4

These figures were no doubt based on his calculation relating to special constituencies, but I hope he will excuse me for a bit of cruel psychology when I say that mention of specific figures was perhaps meant only to decoy me in the belief that he agreed at least to a majority of one for Muslims in the total House. Sir Jogendra accuses me of drawing unfortunate inferences from his proposals. I assure him that in the presence of the specific figures mentioned in his letter no inference was necessary.

5

On the other hand, in spite of these figures, I could not but understand him to mean what he has now plainly stated without the mention of any specific figures, namely, that he offered only a possibility to Muslims for securing more seats out of those allotted to special constituencies.

6

I agree that he offered only a possibility, but if this is the Sikh view of the situation then the Working Committee of the All-India Muslim Conference was right in thinking that there was no likelihood of any material settlement.

7

Again Sir Jogendra says that whatever the offer was, it was not made on behalf of the Sikh community. I do not pretend to know anything about the origin of his proposal. Nor was it necessary to hazard a guess. After giving some important details of his proposal Sir Jogendra himself says in his letter: “...Muslims to give support to Sikhs to secure for them 5 per cent, seats in the Central Legislature, 6 per cent, in the Frontier Province and a seat in the Central Cabinet. The Sikhs will join the Minorities’ Pact.”

8

However, it is unnecessary now to enter into a controversy of the kind. My object in this statement is to make the position of the Working Committee as clear as possible and I hope I have done so.

9

As far as the Sikh-Muslim conversations at Simla are concerned, I must make it plain that although I would welcome any reasonable material settlement, which need not necessarily be prior to the announcement to be made on August 17, 1 cannot, as President of the Muslim Conference, participate in these conversations unless properly authorised by the Working Committee of that body.

Source: Speeches and Statements of Iqbal, compiled by “Shamloo”, Al-Manar Academy, Lahore, 1944 (Delhi scan https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.220327; other copies in.ernet.dli.2015.51949 and the 1948 printing speechesandstatementsofiqbal used to correct the scanned text).