Statement on Sir Jogendra Singh’s proposal for Sikh-Muslim negotiations, published on the 4th August, 1932.
I received, on July 29, from Sardar Sir Jogendra Singh what he described as a short note which, according to him, might form the basis of a discussion and I was asked what I thought of it. I cannot say whether he wrote similar letters to other Muslims* The letter which he sent to me was marked private. It seems, however, that its contents have already been disclosed to the Press.
I would have heartily endorsed a communal pact for the Punjab on a reasonable basis. But the way in which publicity has been given to Sir Jogendra’s note makes me suspect the whole affair.
My reasons, however, for rejecting Sir Jogendra’s proposals were, as mentioned in my reply, that while they were apparently intended to concede to Muslims a majority of one in the total House, they would actually reduce Muslims to an equality with non-Muslims and most probably to a minority.
I further pointed out that Muslims could in no case accept less than 51 per cent, seats and that a concession of 51 per cent, seats to them could not amount to what was being called a Muslim raj.
Seeing that Sir Jogendra meant to arrive at a settlement before the British Government’s announcement, I also wrote to him that the subject of his note could be discussed even after the announcement.
In reply to my letter I received from him on August 3, another letter in which he suggested a totally different scheme which, in my opinion, was as unacceptable to Muslims as the first one. Since, according to an Associated Press message, these negotiations have been communicated to the British Government, my fear is that this may result in delaying the promised announcement by the British Government.
I, therefore, consider it absolutely necessary to, emphasise the fact that since no communal settlement prior or subsequent to the announcement can be acceptable to Muslims unless it provides for 51 per cent, seats for Muslims in the provincial legislature as agreed to in the Minorities’ Pact, it will only aggravate the situation if the announcement is allowed to be delayed by such negotiations.
It is obvious that Sir Jogendra’s proposals recognise the principle of separate electorates to the extent of 150 seats in a total number of 175. His calculations mentioned in his note further give a majority of at least one to Muslims in the total House. In the circumstances I see no reason why our Sikh brethren should not further try to remove Muslim fears of being reduced to a minority or an equality by agreeing to the minimum demands of Muslims which other Indian minorities have already agreed to.