کلامِ اقبالIqbal Repository
Review edition: the Urdu and Persian texts are checked against Iqbal Academy Pakistan editions; English translations and commentary are drafts awaiting review.

2 October 1933

Statement on his rejection of the offer of presidentship of the “Tehrik-i-Kashmir”

Speeches and Statements of IqbalAbout 2 min readDraft text

Long paragraphs are broken into shorter ones for easier reading. The numbers in the margin count the paragraphs of each piece. Notes in square brackets are the compiler’s, as printed.

1

I thought it unfair to the All-India Kashmir Committee, of which I am the President, to reply to the letter containing the offer without giving my Committee an opportunity of expressing its opinion on it. I informed Dr. Mirza Yaqub Beg to that effect. It has been wrongly inferred from my letter by certain writers in the Press who are probably Qadianis that I have no objection on principle to accepting the office which was offered to me. I therefore hasten to make it clear that I have serious objections on principle not only to accepting the offer but even to entertaining it My reasons for this attitude are the same as led me to suggest the reconstitution of the All-India Kashmir Committee some time ago.

2

The offer which has been made to me is obviously a camouflage intended to hoodwink the public into a belief that the old All-India Kashmir Committee still exists as a distinct body from the reconstituted Committee and that the gentlemen who were excluded from the reconstituted Committee are prepared to work under the leadership of the very man who was mainly responsible for the reconstitution.

3

This device, however, cannot convince me or the Muslim public that the reasons which lad me to the reconstitution of the Kashmir Committee have disappeared. No definite declaration has yet emanated from the Qadiani headquarters that in the event of the Qadianis joining a Muslim political organisation, their allegiance will not be divided. On the other hand events have revealed that what the Qadiani Press describes as “Tehrik-i-Kashmir” and in which, according to the Qadiani newspaper Al-Fazl, Muslims were only courteously allowed to participate, has entirely different aims and objects from those of the All-lndia Kashmir Committee. Certain open letters addressed by the head of the Qadiani community to his “Kashmir brethren”— a phrase which appears to have been used in order to avoid the use of the term Muslim for non-Qadiani Kashmiris— disclosed at least some of the inner motives of this Qadiani “Tehrik-i-Kashmir.”

4

In these circumstances I fail to understand how any Muslim can associate himself with a Tehrik which has revealed itself to be the instrument of a specific propaganda even though it seeks to cover itself with a thin veneer of non-sectarianism.

Source: Speeches and Statements of Iqbal, compiled by “Shamloo”, Al-Manar Academy, Lahore, 1944 (Delhi scan https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.220327; other copies in.ernet.dli.2015.51949 and the 1948 printing speechesandstatementsofiqbal used to correct the scanned text).