بہ فغاں نہ لب کشودم کہ فغاں اثر ندارد
غمِ دل نگفتہ بہتر ہمہ کس جگر ندارد
ba fughan na lab kushudam ke fughan asar nadarad
gham-e dil nagufta behtar hama kas jigar nadarad
I did not open my lips to lament, for lament has no effect;
the heart’s grief is better unspoken: not everyone has the heart for it.
Note Numbered 54 in the edition. Printed centred in the edition.
About this poem
In brief
I did not open my lips to lament, for lament has no effect; the heart's grief is better left unsaid, for not everyone has the heart for it. Kaaba or temple, everywhere there is talk of intimacy, yet no one knows the secret between You and me. What a sight is this world, whose spark is kept alive for one breath and not the next! You passed through our eyes into our inmost mind, but so that the eye did not know. None of these connoisseurs looked twice at my gem; I entrust it to You, for the world has no eye for it. The reason-kindling cup Europe gave us is all sun, yet has nothing of the dawn.
The ideas
A ghazal of reticence. Real grief and real intimacy with God cannot be shown in public; the religious talk of shrine and temple misses the private secret. God enters the heart unseen, past the senses. The poet's work, his 'gem', is unappreciated by the world's critics, so he hands it to God. The final couplet is a famous judgement on Western learning: it is all glare and brilliance, but it lacks the gentle, life-giving light of dawn, the light that brings a new day.
History and politics
Zabur-i-Ajam (Persian Psalms, 1927) is Iqbal’s third Persian collection: two parts of ghazal-like lyrics addressed to God and to the reader, followed by the masnavis Gulshan-e Raz-e Jadid and Bandagi Nama.
Why it matters today
The image of European reason as 'all sun but no dawn' is often quoted in debates on modern knowledge without spiritual renewal.
Commentary: Adab AI (draft for review)