حریفِ نکتۂ توحید ہو سکا نہ حکیم
نگاہ چاہیے اسرارِ 'لا الہ' کے لیے
harīf-e-nukta-e-tauhīd ho sakā na hakīm
nigāh chāhiye asrār-e-lā ilah ke liye
The philosopher could not master the point of tawhid;
the secrets of 'There is no god' need vision.
Note Poem 24 of the section Talim o Tarbiyat. harif: match, equal to.
About this poem
In brief
The philosopher could not master the point of tawhid: the secrets of 'There is no god' need vision. His lofty thought is an arrow in the breast of the sky; his imagination is a lasso for sun and moon. Though in his nature his monkishness is pure, it longs for the pleasure of sin.
The ideas
Iqbal admired Nietzsche's daring and his call for a higher man, but held that he stopped at 'la' (no god) and never reached 'illa' (but God). Nietzsche's thought soars, yet it lacks the vision that faith provides. The last couplet suggests an ascetic temperament that nevertheless hungered for forbidden experience.
History and politics
Friedrich Nietzsche (1844-1900), German philosopher. Iqbal discusses him in several works, and in Javid Nama places him beyond the spheres, as one who did not find God.
Commentary: Adab AI (draft for review)