صاحبِ سرمایہ از نسلِ خلیل
یعنی آں پیغمبرِ بے جبرئیل
sahib-e sarmaya az nasl-e khalil
ya‘ni an paighambar-e be-jibra’il
The author of Capital, of the line of Abraham,
that is, that prophet without Gabriel:
Note Masnavi printed in two columns, the two hemistichs side by side. Footnote in the edition: Sahib-e Sarmaya, Karl Marx, the author of the book Capital, who set out the principles of communism in it.
About this poem
In brief
Afghani continues. The author of Capital, of the line of Abraham, is a prophet without Gabriel: truth lies hidden in his falsehood, his heart is a believer while his brain is an unbeliever. Westerners have lost the heavens and seek the pure soul in the belly. The pure soul takes no colour or scent from the body, yet communism has no business except with the body; the religion of that prophet who did not know the Truth rests on equality of bellies. But brotherhood has its station in the heart; its root is in the heart, not in water and clay. Monarchy, too, fattens the body while its unlit breast is empty of heart. Like a bee feeding on a rose, it leaves the petal and takes the honey: branch, leaf, colour and scent stay the same, the nightingale still laments over its beauty, but pass beyond the spell of colour and scent, look to the meaning: though inner death is hard to see, do not call that a rose which is in truth clay. Both have restless, impatient souls; both ignore God and deceive man. For one, life is revolt; for the other, tribute; between these two stones man is glass. One breaks science, religion and art; the other takes the soul from the body and the bread from the hand. I saw both drowned in water and clay, both bright of body and dark of heart. Life is burning while building, sowing the seed of a heart in clay.
The ideas
Iqbal sets communism and capitalist imperialism (mulukiyat, ‘kingship’) side by side as twin materialisms. He credits Marx with a hidden truth, the demand for justice and equality, which is why his ‘heart is a believer’, but faults him for reducing man to the stomach. Imperial capitalism keeps the outward form of civilisation while draining its inner life. True brotherhood, Iqbal argues, can only be founded on the heart and on God.
History and politics
The edition’s footnote explains ‘the author of Capital’ (sahib-e sarmaya) as Karl Marx, the writer of Das Kapital (1867), who set out the principles of communism in that book; ‘of the line of Abraham’ alludes to his Jewish descent. Javid Nama was written a decade after the Russian Revolution, when Iqbal was watching the Soviet experiment with mixed hope and alarm; elsewhere he wrote that Bolshevism plus God would be close to Islam. Javid Nama (The Book of Eternity, 1932) is Iqbal’s Persian masterpiece, a masnavi of about 2,000 couplets dedicated to his son Javid. Modelled on the Prophet’s Mi‘raj and on Dante’s Divine Comedy, it tells of the poet’s journey, as Zinda Rud (the Living Stream), through the spheres of the Moon, Mercury, Venus, Mars, Jupiter and Saturn and beyond, guided by Rumi, meeting the souls of prophets, saints, poets, reformers and traitors.
Islamic concepts
‘His heart is a believer, his brain an unbeliever’ echoes a hadith about the pre-Islamic poet Umayya ibn Abi al-Salt, ‘his tongue believed but his heart disbelieved’, here reversed. The stress on brotherhood (ukhuwwat) rooted in the heart recalls ‘the believers are brothers’ (49:10) and ‘He united your hearts’ (3:103).
Why it matters today
The couplets still describe the two failures Iqbal saw: state systems that promise equality but crush conscience, and market systems that keep the forms of culture while hollowing them out. ‘Between these two stones man is glass’ is a striking image for the individual caught between them.
Commentary: Adab AI (draft for review)