رندانِ فرانسیس کا میخانہ سلامت
پُر ہے مئے گلرنگ سے ہر شیشہ حلب کا
rindān-e-Frāncis kā mai-ḳhāna salāmat
pur hai m'ai-e-gul-rang se har shīsha Halab kā
Long live the tavern of the French revellers;
every flask of Aleppo is full of rose-red wine.
Note Poem 29 of the section Siyasiyat-e-Mashriq o Maghrib. rindan: revellers. Francis: France. Halab: Aleppo.
About this poem
In brief
Long live the tavern of the French revellers: every flask in Aleppo is full of rose-red wine. If the Jew has a right to the soil of Palestine, why do the Arabs have no right to Spain? British imperialism has some other purpose; this is not a story of oranges, honey and dates.
The ideas
Iqbal argues against the historical-claim case for a Jewish homeland by turning it around: if ancient possession grants a right, the Arabs could claim Spain. He sees British policy as driven by imperial strategy rather than the land's produce or sentiment.
History and politics
France held Syria (including Aleppo) under mandate; Britain held Palestine and had promised, in the Balfour Declaration of 1917, a 'national home for the Jewish people' there. Muslims ruled much of Spain from 711 to 1492.
Why it matters today
The question of rights in Palestine remains one of the most contested in the world; the poem records Iqbal's 1930s position, which he also set out in statements on the Peel Commission in 1937.
Commentary: Adab AI (draft for review)